Casein Protein vs. Whey Protein: The Benefits of the ‘Other Protein Powder’

Casein protein - Dr. Axe

Currently the most popular protein powder in the world is whey protein, loved by athletes and those both looking to lose or gain weight. Whey protein has been the go-to muscle enhancer for decades, but there’s another protein supplement out there: casein protein.

One of the top sources of long-lasting amino acids, casein protein — sometimes called “the other protein powder” — provides easy-to-digest protein in a similar fashion to whey. What makes casein protein different from whey protein, pea protein powder, or even whole foods like eggs and chicken breast? One of casein’s greatest advantages is the timing of how it’s absorbed, plus how long it lingers in the body. Both factors make it beneficial for building muscle fast and preserving the body’s lean muscle tissue.

When it comes to nutrient timing, the type of protein matters. Casein protein hits your bloodstream very quickly — plus its amino acids stay where they need to be in order to help build muscle tissue for many hours, as opposed to being flushed from the body relatively quickly.

So, looking to build lean muscle mass, curb hunger and see even more benefits from your exercise (and who isn’t)? Then perhaps you might want to start using casein protein … or is it better to have this protein in pure food form and stay away from this controversial protein powder. Answers ahead.


What Is Casein Protein?

Derived from milk, just like whey protein, casein protein is actually a naturally more abundant source of branched-chain amino acids. That’s why it’s sometimes simply called “milk protein,” since around 80 percent of the protein found in cow’s milk is casein — and it also makes up 20 to 40 percent of human breast milk. It’s also abundant in raw sheep cheese, a pure source of casein.

Casein, like whey and other protein foods, is made up of various “building blocks” called essential and non-essential amino acids. The human body is able to make certain amino acids on its own (called non-essential) while others it cannot (called essential), making the essential kinds crucial to get through the foods you eat. Since plant foods don’t always provide the complete set of essential amino acids we need, animal foods — and sometimes convenient protein powders — are one way people make sure they cover their protein bases.

Casein protein powder is created in a lab from dehydrating parts of milk — the problem is that many forms are denatured and isolated, and may cause health issues. You’ll want to try to find casein protein that is from A2 beta-casein rather than A1 casein (see “Different Types of Casein Protein” below). You can usually find it in most health food stores and might come across a variety of flavors. What you’ll probably notice is that for every brand of casein protein powder available, about five different whey protein powders are also sold.


Casein Protein vs. Whey Protein

For athletes, or really anyone who’s pretty active, protein is an important piece of the puzzle when it comes to muscle recovery, repair and growth. While most people living in developed nations are far from suffering a protein deficiency, keep in mind that protein requirements increase the more active you become, and they’re especially high when you regularly lift weights or do other types of lengthy training.

While you might think that protein powders are only for serious lifters, bulky men or pro athletes, nearly everyone can benefit from supplementing workouts with the right mix of nutrients — and protein powders simply make this easier to do.

We already know the difference between whey protein and soy protein. So what about whey and casein?

Whey protein and casein protein differ in terms of their bioavailability and effects on muscle synthesis. Although whey protein has many of the same benefits, it’s believed to cause more of a fast “amino acid spike” compared to casein. (1) When the body is flooded with more protein that it can use at one time, it’s possible for some to be flushed out through urine, oxidized or generally wasted.

However, this isn’t always a bad thing — different types of proteins have their upsides — so don’t go writing off whey protein just yet. There are certainly benefits to consuming both faster- and slower-releasing proteins; it really just comes down to your goals and schedule.

At the molecular level, within a protein source like casein various amino acids are branched together. Casein protein has a lower percentage of branched-chain amino acid compared to whey protein, which is one reason it’s slower to digest and also tends to work for longer. Because of its utilization and timing, casein increases protein synthesis a bit less than whey does. (2)

On the plus side, it better stops the body from breaking down amino acids it already has available within your muscles. Whey protein also has more sulfur than casein, which can also change the way the body uses it. Compared to casein, whey is a fast protein source, which means it provides amino acids quickly after ingestion — however they also leave the body sooner than when you consume casein.

In theory, the two should work differently to affect body composition, however not every study has shown this to be true. For example, researchers from the Metabolism Unit at the University of Texas Medical Branch found that short-term ingestion of both whey and casein after exercise resulted in similar increases in muscle protein net balance. They didn’t actually result in differences in muscle protein synthesis despite different patterns of blood amino acid responses. (3)

If all of this chemistry seems a bit confusing, here’s the bottom line on casein vs. whey. Both casein and whey protein can supplement your workouts well and include all the essential amino acids you need, but whey has more branched-chain amino acids and, therefore, might be slightly better at facilitating muscle protein synthesis.

The good news is this: After comparing the effects of both proteins on body composition and performance in female athletes, researchers from the Exercise and Performance Nutrition Laboratory at the University of South Florida found that whey and casein had similar positive effects. Females were found to experience benefits using both supplements, including an increase in performance markers from consuming protein after resistance training and a decreased body fat composition. (4)

 

Casein protein vs. whey protein - Dr. Axe

 


Casein Protein Benefits

When used at the time right, high-quality casein protein is useful for:

  • Building new muscle tissue and promoting lean muscle growth (5)
  • Repairing broken-down muscle fibers after a workout while you sleep
  • Preserving muscle you already have (making it anti-catabolic)
  • Restoring nitrogen balance during muscle recovery (6)
  • Curbing your appetite
  • Regulating blood sugar levels
  • Helping prevent overeating
  • Potentially helping with weight loss/maintenance

Let’s go into a little more detail about some of casein protein’s major benefits and uses (7):

1. Helps Build Muscle Mass and Spare Muscle-Wasting

Casein is usually known as an “anti-catabolic” protein. What exactly does this mean? Your body catabolizes, or basically tears down, muscle tissue to get the amino acids that are stored inside muscle protein. It uses these stored amino acids for energy and helping with various functions, such as growth and development. (8)

The more you exercise, the more your body is going to search for available protein to keep it functioning. Anti-catabolic supplements provide amino acids that help minimize this breakdown process, sparing you hard-earned muscle mass.

2. Lasts Longer than Other Protein Sources

Although it’s absorbed quickly, casein is still considered a relatively “slow-digesting” protein because of the length of time its amino acids stay within the bloodstream. Just like slower-releasing carbohydrates are beneficial as opposed to fast-acting types that can spike blood sugar rapidly, protein foods can sometimes work the same way.

The body can slowly digest casein protein, which means muscle tissues have a longer opportunity to use the amino acids for repair work and growth. As you’ll learn below, the timing of casein definitely has its advantages, however depending on your goals there are certain times you want to skip casein and use a faster-acting protein instead.

3. Makes a Great Meal Replacement or Pre-Bedtime Snack

Did you know that sleep is one of the most important times for building muscle mass and benefiting from the hard work or exercise you do during the day? That’s because while you’re sleeping, your body is works to repair areas that have been overly stressed during the day. One of the ways you can take advantage of this biological process is using casein protein to give your muscles an extra boost.

Casein protein is believed to linger in the bloodstream for up to seven hours, which is one reason that bodybuilders love consuming casein right before bed. In the fitness community, casein protein has gained a reputation for being an “ideal nighttime snack.”

A study conducted by the Department of Human Movement Sciences at NUTRIM School for Nutrition found that casein protein ingested immediately before sleep is effectively digested and absorbed, helping stimulate muscle protein synthesis and improving “whole-body protein balance” following exercise. (9) Throughout the night while someone is sleeping, amino acids work to build muscle fibers back stronger. In addition to having casein before bed, it makes a great shake/snack to have between meals when you’re going several hours or more without eating.

4. May Help Curb Your Appetite and Help with Weight Loss

Even if you only exercise in a “moderate” way and aren’t looking to put on muscle mass, protein supplements can still be beneficial when it comes to curbing hunger and cravings. Many people choose to use protein powders for their convenience coupled with the fact that they can suppress your appetite to a certain extent.

Ever notice when you eat a carb- or sugar-heavy breakfast, but skip out on protein, that you’re reaching for something else to eat shortly after? Protein is very satisfying and can help you go from one meal to the next without hunger pangs and sugar cravings. Most people who include a protein source with every meal (and even snacks) find that they can manage their hunger and food choices better overall. While the effects differ depending on the person, some people do really well using protein powders along with other nutrient-packed ingredients in smoothies as an easy breakfast, a high-protein snack or even as a meal replacement.

How well can casein protein control your hunger compared to whey protein? A study published in the British Journal of Nutrition found that both work very similarly. Researchers compared the hunger-reducing effects of hydrolyzed casein protein, intact casein and intact whey protein in 24 overweight adult men and women. They wanted to determine the effects these different protein supplements have on overall energy expenditure (EE) and appetite regulation, essentially the amount of “calories in versus calories out.”

The two types of casein and the one type of whey protein all had similar effects over the course of 24 hours on EE and appetite, although some results suggested whey protein seemed to work somewhat better when it came to positively affecting the subjects’ resting metabolic rates. (10)


The Best Times to Use Casein Protein

Ideally, you want to use casein protein before bed (if your goal is to build muscle and potentially gain weight) or as a meal replacement/snack between spaced-out meals. Remember that casein is digested slowly, which means following a workout it will take longer than other types of protein (such as whey) to reach your muscles.

Since you want to supply your damaged muscle tissue with nutrients ASAP following exercise, using casein over faster-acting protein sources won’t give you the benefits of an immediate rush of amino acids that you’re after. Because whey protein is so quickly absorbed and digested, it makes the better choice following a workout. Your muscles are searching for a rapid supply of nutrients after you train in order to carry out muscle synthesis, so hold off on having casein to better speed up this process.


Casein Protein Powder Nutrition Facts

Wondering how much casein protein you should use at one time or maybe how much protein  you need in general? Protein needs vary from person to person depending on many factors, but some general guidelines are as follows (11):

  • about 0.68–1 gram of protein per pound of body weight if you’re an athlete or highly active person
  • about 0.45–0.68 gram per pound of body weight if you’re looking to lose weight and tone up
  • about 0.36 gram per pound of body weight to generally maintain your health and weight

Depending on the brand of casein protein powder you buy, the calories and protein amounts can vary. To get the most benefits, look for a brand that’s low in sugar or sweetened naturally with organic stevia extract and natural sweeteners like cocoa powder or vanilla extract. In general, a serving of casein powder has around:

  • 120 calories
  • 23 grams protein
  • 1 gram fat
  • 1 gram sugar
  • 450 milligrams calcium (45 percent)

To put this into context, a women who weights 140 pounds who’s active and wants to improve her diet might aim to eat up to 63–95 grams of protein a day, which means a serving of casein protein could cover her needs for one of her three main meals.

 

Casein protein nutrition - Dr. Axe

 


Different Types of Casein Protein: A1 vs. A2 Casein

Milk is composed of about 85 percent water and 15 percent sugar (called lactose), protein, fat and minerals. Among the protein compounds in milk, there is more than one kind. A2 beta-casein is the type that has been produced naturally by animals for thousands of years, even before they were first domesticated more than 10,000 years ago. It’s believed to be easier to digest, and some research suggests it has much fewer effects on human health than the other type, called A1 casein.

A1 is the “newer type of casein,” which first developed sometime in the past few thousand years following animal domestication. It came about after certain genes caused proteins to change, resulting in proline amino acids changing over to histidine. Today, A1 beta-casein is more abundant in dairy cows that are used to produce the vast majority of milk in the U.S. and even Europe.

Each cow has a certain genotype of A1/A1, A1/A2 or A2/A2 that ultimately affects the milk it produces. It’s preferable to consume milk products, including all dairy foods and whey/casein protein supplements, made from cows (or goats) that predominantly contain A2 casein. How come?

When A1 beta-casein caused a switch from proline to histidine amino acids, it resulted in problems with humans digesting and properly metabolizing milk. In fact, most people who are intolerant of cow milk are actually sensitive to one of the proteins found in it, A1 casein. They essentially lack the ability to digest A1. This intolerance is now linked to a wide range of illnesses, including autoimmune reactions, food allergies, digestive issues, type 1 diabetes, heart disease and more. A1 is also thought to promote inflammation, however milk that contains mostly or exclusively A2 casein produces far fewer (or zero) inflammatory effects.

How do you know if the casein or whey protein you’re consuming comes from A1 or A2 cows? There are a large variety of mixed-breed dairy cow herds that are thought to produce A2 milk, including Jersey, Guernsey, Brown Swiss, milking shorthorn, Friesian and others. Buying products made from these breeds (and ideally kinds that are labeled organic and grass-fed too) should result in lower amounts of A1 beta-casein. Some protein supplements fuse both dairy proteins into one product.


What About the Dairy: Can You Have Casein Protein If You’re Lactose-Intolerant?

By now you already know that casein protein comes from milk, very likely cow’s milk. Conventional cow’s milk (that is homogenized and pasteurized) is usually the culprit for lactose intolerance and is a common allergy. It contains more than 20 different allergens (including A1 casein) that can cause allergic reactions or digestive problems like a bloated stomach, diarrhea or abdominal cramping.

If you’ve suffered from the symptoms of lactose intolerance in the past and have trouble digesting milk-derivative products, I encourage you to try raw milk, goat’s milk and organic A2 milk. One option is to find casein protein made from goat milk, since goat milk naturally contains only A2 casein.

Goat milk is considered similar to human breast milk and tends to cause less digestive issues or allergic reactions than cow milk. Also source A2 casein protein products made from breeds of cows that don’t produce A1 casein, namely Jersey and Guernsey cows. You need to do your research because, unfortunately, the majority of bovines in the U.S., Western Europe and Australia are Holstein and Fresian cows, which are A1 casein producers.


Casein Protein Takeaways

Casein protein has many of the same benefits as whey protein, so if you’re looking for an alternative protein source to whey, casein is your best option. However, remember that casein is slower-acting than whey, which means it takes longer to reach the muscles and longer to leave the body. As such, if you’re looking to put on muscle mass quickly, whey may be the better option.

However, casein works especially well while you’re sleeping — helping your body repair muscles and even strengthen them thanks to its slow-acting effect. But remember, when you buy and consume casein, look for A2 casein from organic and grass-fed cows or goats. It can difficult to discern between A1 and A2 casein, but your best bet is going with the most natural sources, since A2 is the healthier, more natural form of casein that’s been produced long before animal domestication.

If you keep all this in mind, you can get the most benefits from your protein sources, keeping your muscles healthy and your weight in check!

Read Next: How Many Grams of Protein Per Day Do You Need?


From the sound of it, you might think leaky gut only affects the digestive system, but in reality it can affect more. Because Leaky Gut is so common, and such an enigma, I’m offering a free webinar on all things leaky gut. Click here to learn more about the webinar.


Josh Axe

Dr. Josh Axe is on a mission to provide you and your family with the highest quality nutrition tips and healthy recipes in the world...Sign up to get VIP access to his eBooks and valuable weekly health tips for FREE!

Get FREE Access!

Free eBook to boost
metabolism & healing

30 Gluten-Free Recipes
& detox juicing guide

Shopping Guide &
premium newsletter