Sweeteners · Added Sugars

Cane Sugar vs. White Sugar: Nutrition, Health Risks & Better Swaps

What cane sugar is, how it compares with white sugar, beet sugar and high-fructose corn syrup, what the trials show it does to your liver, weight and blood pressure, and the swaps to use instead.

By Dr. Josh Axe, DC, DNM, CNS·20-min read

Meet the Medical Advisory Board

Evidence-based60 sources citedUpdated October 15, 2026

Published Oct 1, 2026Last updated Oct 15, 2026Editorial policyMedical review policyFact-checking policy

The Dr. Axe Score™

2.9/10

Overall Dr. Axe Score · Cane Sugar vs. White Sugar

Refining strips sugarcane juice down to sucrose, and the score reflects that loss: a large body of research that points toward harm at the amounts people eat, almost no antioxidant capacity left in the crystals, and no meaningful nutrients per serving.

Scientific Evidence

7.2/10

A large research base: randomized trials, meta-analyses and big cohorts. This factor rates how much research exists, not which way it points.

Antioxidant & Anti-Inflammatory

1.0/10

Under 0.01 mmol of antioxidant capacity per 100 grams in lab testing; sucrose raised two inflammation markers in a 10-week trial.

Clinical Effectiveness

1.4/10

Our judgment: no dietary benefit beyond calories and cooking uses; trials link it to more liver fat, weight gain and higher blood pressure.

Nutrient Density

0.5/10

Rated against raw honey, its swap: every mineral comes to hundredths of a milligram or less per teaspoon.

Why this score?

Why Cane Sugar vs. White Sugar scores 2.9 / 10

How the score works: Scientific Evidence rates research amount and quality; Antioxidant & Anti-Inflammatory, protective compounds and measured effects; Clinical Effectiveness, the team's judgment of real-world usefulness (human trials, traditional use and Dr. Axe's clinical experience); Nutrient Density, per serving against raw honey. These are editorial judgments, not clinical measurements.
Weighting: Evidence 30% · Antioxidant & Anti-Inflammatory 25% · Clinical Effectiveness 25% · Nutrient Density 20% (7.2×0.30 + 1.0×0.25 + 1.4×0.25 + 0.5×0.20 = 2.86, shown as 2.9).

A transparent, weighted index built for foods. See how it’s calculated →

Dr. Axe Protocol

Insulin Resistance & Prediabetes

90-day protocol

The complete root-cause framework for lowering insulin, bringing HbA1c back to healthy and stopping prediabetes before it becomes diabetes — with the labs to prove it’s working.

A self-check
The four-phase plan
A 7-day meal plan

Free with your Dr. Axe account

View the protocol →

Cane sugar at a glance

Cane sugar is sucrose crystallized from the juice of sugarcane, and your body handles it the same way it handles white table sugar. A teaspoon adds 16 calories and 4.2 grams of sugar with almost nothing else, and white and turbinado sugar are both more than 99% sucrose.1 2

Dr. Axe's view: be very careful with cane sugar. Less-refined cane sugar is a better choice than refined, processed sugar, but it's still sugar, very low in nutrients, and not healthy. Honey is a far superior option, and even honey should be used sparingly.
Same as granulated sugar: chemically, yes, though a U.S. bag labeled only "sugar" may come from sugar beets3
What cutting back does: less liver fat, easier weight control, and lower blood pressure and triglycerides in controlled trials4 5 6
Dr. Axe's swap: raw honey first, in small amounts, then monk fruit, stevia or allulose, never artificial sweeteners
How much: the 2025–2030 Dietary Guidelines cap one meal at 10 grams of added sugar7

Cane sugar starts as the sweet juice pressed from the stalks of sugarcane, a tall tropical grass. Mills boil that juice down and spin the crystals free of their dark syrup, which is molasses, and refining washes away most of what's left. Fully refined, it's 99.8% sucrose, with no fiber, protein or fat, and a bag labeled "cane sugar" or "pure cane sugar" can be exactly that: white sugar that came from cane instead of beets.1 3

Cane sugar is on the avoid list in The Biblio Diet, the book I wrote with Jordan Rubin, and that includes organic and "all-natural" cane sugar.8 Added sugar is one of the book's Sinister Six, the foods to drop first. The reason goes to the root cause: nowhere in nature would you get that much sugar as an isolated compound. Whole fruit and raw honey bring fiber, antioxidants or enzymes along with their sugar; refined sugar has none of them.9

So I'd be very careful with cane sugar. In its less-refined forms it's natural, and it's a better choice than refined, processed sugar, but it's still sugar: it's very low in nutrients, and it's not healthy at all. Honey is a far superior option. Raw honey is my number-one sweetener, and it's what I'd use in place of cane sugar in any dish or dessert.10 11 Even so, everyone should be careful with natural sugars too, and as the Bible says, even honey should be used sparingly: "It is not good to eat much honey" (Proverbs 25:27, KJV).

As a carbohydrate, honey teaches us that context matters: Sugar in isolation is harmful, but sugar packaged in a matrix of antioxidants and enzymes can be healing.Dr. Josh Axe, DC, DNM, CNSFrom Heal Your Cells (2026), p. 138

Get the free Insulin Resistance & Prediabetes protocol

Cutting sugar is where steadier blood sugar starts. This free 90-day protocol lays out:

Four phases, in order
The foods that lower insulin, plus a 7-day meal plan
A quick check for insulin resistance, and how to test, ranked

Free with your Dr. Axe account (email or Google). You'll also get the protocol's short email series and the Dr. Axe newsletter; unsubscribe anytime.

Open the free protocol →

Did you know?

Since 2016, the FDA has advised that sweeteners made from sugarcane be declared on labels as "sugar," not "evaporated cane juice."12
Sugar water eases newborns' pain during medical procedures: in a review of 74 trials with 7,049 infants, the heel-prick trials found that 24% sucrose given beforehand lowered scores on a standard infant pain scale by about 1.7 points 30 seconds later, rated high-quality evidence.13
In blind tests with 100 tasters, beet and cane sugar could be told apart by smell, but not by taste once their noses were clipped.14

What is cane sugar?

Quick answer

Cane sugar is sucrose made from the juice of sugarcane, a tall tropical grass. Each sucrose molecule is one glucose joined to one fructose, and white granulated sugar is 99.8% sucrose by weight, with no free glucose or fructose.1

Cane sugars differ in how much molasses they keep. Turbinado and other "raw" sugars are crystals that keep a thin coat of molasses, brown sugar carries more of it, and panela and jaggery are the whole juice boiled down until it sets into a block.15

A short history of cane sugar

Sugarcane's story starts in the Pacific. A 2025 genetic study of 390 cane samples traced the crop to the New Guinea region, where it was domesticated from a wild cane, and found that people then carried it into mainland Asia, where it crossed with wild relatives.58 The King James Version names honey 56 times, and the honeycomb 9 more, but never mentions sugar.

In 1965, the Sugar Research Foundation, an industry trade group, sponsored a review of the research on diet and heart disease that later ran in a leading medical journal. It singled out fat and cholesterol and played down sucrose; the foundation set the review's objective, supplied articles and saw drafts, and its role wasn't disclosed. Researchers pieced that together from the group's own documents in 2016.16 In the decades after that review, independent trials tied added sugar to higher blood pressure and blood fats, and cohorts linked it to deaths from cardiovascular disease.6 17

Is cane sugar the same as granulated sugar?

Quick answer

Yes, chemically: cane sugar and white granulated sugar are both sucrose. The difference is the plant. In the U.S., sugar beets supply 55% to 60% of the sugar produced at home and sugarcane 40% to 45%, so a bag labeled only "sugar" or "granulated sugar" may come from beets.3

U.S. sugarcane grows in Florida, Louisiana and Texas.3 Nearly all U.S. sugar beets are genetically engineered to tolerate herbicides; those varieties covered 98% of sugar beet acreage in 2013.18 A package that says "cane sugar" tells you the sugar didn't come from those crops.

Is cane sugar healthier than white sugar or corn syrup?

Quick answer

In Dr. Axe's view, less-refined cane sugar is a better choice than refined, processed sugar, but it's still sugar and not healthy. "Better" means less processing and a trace of what the cane started with: turbinado and brown sugar keep some molasses, so they carry a few more milligrams of minerals per teaspoon than white sugar, and all three are 94% to 99.8% sucrose.1 2 19

Cane sugar types compared, per teaspoon unless noted
Type	What it is	Sucrose	Per teaspoon
White granulated sugar	Fully refined crystals, from cane or beets	99.8%	16 calories; 0.08 mg potassium; 0.04 mg calcium1
Turbinado ("raw") sugar	Partly refined crystals with some molasses left on	99.2%	18 calories; 1.3 mg potassium; 0.55 mg calcium2
Brown sugar	Sugar crystals with molasses	94.6%	17 calories; 6.1 mg potassium; 3.8 mg calcium (packed)19
Panela or jaggery	The whole cane juice, boiled down and set	91.9% to 95.5% in tested panela	Total phenolics 0.4% to 0.6% and flavonoids 0.2% to 0.4% by weight15
Evaporated cane juice	An older label name for cane sugar	Same as sugar	The FDA says to label it "sugar"12
Molasses	The syrup spun off the crystals	29.4% (74.7% total sugars)	Per tablespoon: 58 calories, 292 mg potassium, 48 mg magnesium20

Those extra minerals come in single milligrams per teaspoon, and antioxidant testing tells the same story. In lab measurements, refined sugar had under 0.01 millimoles of antioxidant capacity per 100 grams and raw cane sugar 0.2; honey measured 0.16, maple syrup and brown sugar 0.4 to 0.7, and dark and blackstrap molasses 4.6 to 4.9.21

That's what "better" means when I say less-refined cane sugar beats refined, processed sugar: less processing, a trace of minerals and antioxidants, and no corn syrup. At the amounts anyone should eat, those traces don't add anything meaningful to your diet.

If it's a choice between cane sugar and high-fructose corn syrup, I'd take cane sugar, though you don't want to eat a bunch of either.22 Glyphosate is part of my reason. USDA organic rules don't allow synthetic herbicides such as glyphosate or genetically engineered crops,23 while non-organic sugarcane can itself be sprayed with glyphosate before harvest to raise its sugar content.24 Inside your body, the two sweeteners act much the same. In an NIH-funded trial, 75 adults drank beverages sweetened with sucrose or high-fructose corn syrup at 25% of their daily calories for 16 days; both raised liver fat from baseline and lowered insulin sensitivity compared with an artificially sweetened control, and no outcome differed between the two sugars.25

Cane sugar nutrition facts

Quick answer

One teaspoon of granulated sugar (4.2 grams) has 16 calories and 4.2 grams of carbohydrate, all of it sucrose, with no fiber, protein or fat. Its minerals come to hundredths of a milligram or less: 0.04 milligrams of calcium and 0.08 milligrams of potassium.1

Calculated from USDA FoodData Central FDC ID 169655 (Sugars, granulated) at the record's own teaspoon weight of 4.2 grams. The record doesn't say whether the sugar came from cane or beets.1

Nutrient	1 teaspoon (4.2 g)	Per 100 g
Calories	16	387
Carbohydrate	4.2 g	100 g
Total sugars (all sucrose)	4.2 g	99.8 g
Fiber	0 g	0 g
Protein	0 g	0 g
Fat	0 g	0 g
Calcium	0.04 mg	1 mg
Potassium	0.08 mg	2 mg
Iron	0.002 mg	0.05 mg
Selenium	0.03 mcg	0.6 mcg

A teaspoon gives you energy and nothing else your body needs. Sucrose averages a glycemic index of 65 on a scale where glucose is 100, between the low (55 or less) and high (70 or more) ranges, because its fructose half barely raises blood sugar; fructose on its own scores 15.59

What to use instead of cane sugar

Quick answer

Raw honey is Dr. Axe's number-one replacement for cane sugar, followed by monk fruit, stevia and allulose.10 Maple syrup, coconut sugar and date paste are also on Dr. Axe's sweetener list.8 Honey, maple syrup, coconut sugar and date paste are still sugars, so use them sparingly, in place of cane sugar and never on top of it.26

Dr. Axe's sweetener swaps, in order
Swap	Where it ranks	How to use it
Raw honey	Number one: far superior to cane sugar, still used sparingly	2 teaspoons of honey for each tablespoon of sugar, in recipes that don't need heat8
Monk fruit, stevia, allulose	Next best	Few or no calories; a few people get stomach upset from stevia27
Maple syrup, coconut sugar	On Dr. Axe's sweetener list	In small amounts, in place of sugar8
Date paste	On Dr. Axe's sweetener list	Blend dates with water and swap it one to one for sugar8
Artificial sweeteners, sugar alcohols	Not a swap	Aspartame, sucralose, sorbitol and maltitol stay off the menu8 27

I consider honey a far superior option to cane sugar, and the research gives good reasons. In lab testing, store-bought honey carried 0.16 millimoles of antioxidant capacity per 100 grams, against under 0.01 for refined sugar.21 In a University of Toronto meta-analysis of 18 controlled trials with 1,105 people, a median 40 grams of honey a day (about 2 tablespoons) for 8 weeks raised HDL cholesterol by about 2.7 mg/dL, the review's most certain finding. It also lowered fasting blood sugar by about 3.6 mg/dL, LDL cholesterol by about 6 mg/dL, triglycerides by about 11.5 mg/dL and the liver enzyme ALT by 9.75 units per liter, findings the authors rated low certainty. Raw honey and two single-flower honeys, robinia and clover, showed the clearest benefits for fasting blood sugar and total cholesterol; most of the trials compared honey with people's usual diet rather than with sugar.28

Honey is still sugar, though, about 82% by weight,60 so I'd be careful with it too, as with every natural sugar. Scripture says it plainly: "Hast thou found honey? eat so much as is sufficient for thee, lest thou be filled therewith, and vomit it" (Proverbs 25:16, KJV).

Know what a spoonful carries. A teaspoon of honey has about 21 calories and 5.7 grams of sugar; a tablespoon has about 64 calories and 17 grams.60

Expect an upgrade, not a cut. Two teaspoons of honey, the swap for a tablespoon of sugar, carry about 11.5 grams of sugar in place of 12.6, so the swap changes the kind of sugar far more than the amount.1 8 60

Stay under the per-meal cap. Honey counts as added sugar, and the Dietary Guidelines' 10-gram limit for one meal works out to a little under 2 teaspoons of honey.7 60

Choose raw. Raw honey is Dr. Axe's pick, and it was among the honeys with the clearest benefits in the meta-analysis above.10 28

Never before age 1, and not with a bee allergy. Don't give honey in any amount to a baby younger than 1 year old,29 and if you have asthma or have had a severe reaction to bee stings or bee products, don't assume honey is safe for you.

Coconut sugar, made from the sap of coconut palm blossoms, is mostly sucrose,30 and Medjool dates bring fiber along with their sugar. Stacking honey, maple syrup and coconut sugar on top of cane sugar only adds to the sugar load.26 One swap I don't recommend is artificial sweeteners, such as aspartame and sucralose.27 Sugar alcohols such as sorbitol and maltitol are on my avoid list too.8 For more options, see sugar substitutes.

Is cane sugar bad for you?

Quick answer

Yes. Dr. Axe's position is that cane sugar isn't healthy at all: it's still sugar, and it's very low in nutrients. In controlled trials, cutting added sugar lowered liver fat, body weight and triglycerides, and adding sucrose raised liver fat and blood pressure.4 5 6 31

An umbrella review of 73 meta-analyses found harmful links between dietary sugar and 45 health outcomes, with the best evidence for body weight and fat stored in the liver and other organs. Its authors recommended keeping free or added sugars under 25 grams a day.32 That's the research behind my caution, and it applies to raw, organic and less-refined cane sugar as much as to the white kind.

Where the research stands

Sucrose has been fed to people directly in randomized trials, and added sugar has been studied in meta-analyses pooling 30 to 39 trials and in cohorts of more than 100,000 people. The trials cited here ran from 9 days to 6 months and measured markers such as liver fat and blood fats; the disease findings come from cohort studies, and the largest effects there are for sugary drinks.32 33

How sugar works in your body

Sucrose splits into glucose and fructose in your small intestine, and each half takes its own path. Here's the chain from spoonful to liver fat, step by step, with the proposed steps labeled.

1Sucrose splits in two.

In your small intestine, each sucrose molecule is cut into one glucose and one fructose.34

2Glucose calls for insulin.

It enters your blood, and insulin moves it into your cells to be burned for energy.

3Fructose goes to the liver.

Your liver handles most of it, and researchers propose that the way it breaks fructose down, which uses up energy and releases uric acid, pushes it to store fat (proposed).34

4The liver makes more fat (measured in people).

Men on a daily sucrose drink made new liver fat at more than twice the rate of men who skipped sugary drinks,35 and in a 16-day trial, sucrose drinks raised liver fat and blood uric acid compared with an artificially sweetened drink.25

5Cells respond less to insulin (measured; the link to liver fat is proposed).

In that same 16-day trial, insulin sensitivity fell, even after accounting for changes in weight.25 Kept up, that's the path to insulin resistance, and researchers see fatty liver as part of the same metabolic picture.34

Here's that first trial in detail. In a trial of 94 healthy young men in which neither the men nor the researchers knew who got what, those who added a drink with 80 grams of sucrose a day (about 19 teaspoons) to their usual diet for 7 weeks had a liver fat-making rate of 20.8% a day, the rate at which the liver built new fat and released it into the blood. Men who skipped sugary drinks measured 9.1%, so the sucrose group's rate was more than twice as high, even though total calories were similar across the groups.35

Men on a daily sucrose drink made new liver fat at more than twice the rate of men who skipped sugary drinks

Source: Geidl-Flueck et al. · J Hepatol, 2021 [35]Median rate at which the liver made new fat and released it into the blood; total calorie intake was similar across groups.

I describe insulin resistance as cellular overwhelm: cells so flooded with sugar that their insulin receptors stop responding. They go deaf, and sugar stays in your bloodstream instead of fueling your cells.36

What cutting back does for you, ranked by evidence

Ranked by evidence, cutting back on cane sugar and other added sugars is best for lowering liver fat, managing your weight, bringing down blood pressure and triglycerides, lowering type 2 diabetes risk from sugary drinks, protecting your heart and protecting your teeth.

Less liver fat

Strong evidenceHuman studyRandomized trials · 40 and 47 people

I believe excess sugar and refined carbohydrates are the single biggest driver of liver fat buildup,37 and the trials line up with that. In 40 adolescent boys with fatty liver, a diet with almost no free sugar (added sugars and fruit juice under 3% of calories, with meals provided for the whole household) lowered liver fat from 25% to 17% in 8 weeks, while boys on their usual diet went from 21% to 20%.4 Going the other way, a 6-month trial assigned 47 overweight adults to a liter a day of sucrose-sweetened cola, milk, diet cola or water. Liver fat rose 132% to 143% more in the cola group than in the other three, even though total body fat didn't differ significantly among them.31

Cutting free sugar: liver fat 25% to 17% in 8 weeks

Source: Schwimmer et al. · JAMA, 2019 [4]Liver fat measured by MRI; the adjusted difference at week 8 was 6.23 percentage points.

Easier weight control

Strong evidenceHuman studyMeta-analysis · 30 trials, 38 cohorts

In trials where people ate freely, cutting sugars lowered body weight by 0.80 kilograms (about 1.8 pounds) and adding sugars raised it by 0.75 kilograms. When sugar was swapped for other carbohydrates at the same calories, weight didn't change, which shows the effect runs through the extra calories sugar adds.5

Lower blood pressure and triglycerides

Strong evidenceHuman studyMeta-analysis · 39 randomized trials

Across 39 randomized trials, diets higher in sugar raised triglycerides by about 10 mg/dL and LDL cholesterol by about 5 mg/dL, with HDL up slightly. In the trials that ran 8 weeks or longer, they also raised blood pressure by 6.9/5.6 mmHg, a rise that weight change didn't explain.6 In 43 children with obesity and metabolic syndrome, cutting sugar from 28% to 10% of calories for 9 days, with starch in its place, lowered triglycerides by 46% and diastolic blood pressure by 5 mmHg; that study had no control group, and the children still lost a little weight.38

Lower type 2 diabetes risk, starting with drinks

Moderate evidenceHuman studyDose-response meta-analysis · 29 cohorts

In a 2025 analysis pooling 29 cohort studies, each daily serving of a sugar-sweetened drink was linked to 25% higher risk of type 2 diabetes, rated moderate certainty, though total sucrose intake wasn't (each 20 grams a day tracked with 5% lower risk).33 That's one more reason to cut the drinks first. See the diabetic diet plan.

A healthier heart

Moderate evidenceHuman studyCohorts · 11,733 U.S. and 110,497 U.K. adults

U.S. adults who got 10% to 24.9% of their calories from added sugar had 30% higher risk of dying from cardiovascular disease over a median 14.6 years than those under 10%, and those at 25% or more had 2.75 times the risk.17 In the U.K. Biobank, each 5% of calories from free sugars was linked to 7% more cardiovascular disease, including 6% more ischemic heart disease and 10% more stroke.39

Fewer cavities

Moderate evidenceHuman studySystematic review for the WHO · 55 studies

In a review done for the World Health Organization, 42 of 50 studies in children and all 5 in adults found at least one link between sugar and tooth decay, and moderate-quality evidence showed fewer cavities when sugar stayed under 10% of calories.40

Three markers that show how your body handles sugar

HbA1c reflects a three-month average;41 fasting insulin and triglycerides are snapshots from the same draw. Targets are Dr. Axe's functional ranges.

HbA1c: Your average blood sugar over about three months. The optimal range is 4.8% to 5.3%.
Fasting insulin: How hard your body works to hold blood sugar steady. The optimal range is 2 to 8 µIU/mL.
Triglycerides: A blood fat that rises with added sugar in controlled trials.6

See the cellular bloodwork panel

Have results? Analyze them free →

Does sugar cause inflammation?

It can, and the trials that tested sucrose directly show it in specific markers. As I've written, "Too much sugar triggers cellular stress that drives inflammation, disrupts hormones, and clogs up our detox pathways."42

In a 10-week trial of 41 overweight adults, the group given sucrose-sweetened drinks and foods saw haptoglobin rise 13% and transferrin 5%, two blood proteins used as inflammation markers, while the group given artificially sweetened versions saw them fall 16% and 2%. CRP moved the same way, up 6% versus down 26%, but that difference wasn't statistically significant.43

The Anti-Inflammatory Reset protocol puts the practical side plainly: "Refined carbs, sugar-sweetened drinks and fried food push inflammation up meal by meal."44 See foods that cause inflammation.

Does sugar feed cancer?

My answer, from my Cancer Support Protocol, is that it's more nuanced than the slogan: steady blood sugar and lower insulin support a healthier terrain and are tied to better outcomes, which is a good reason to cut refined sugar without fear-based extremes.45

The cohort data support cutting back, especially on added sugar and sugary drinks. In NutriNet-Santé, a French study of 101,279 adults followed for a median 5.9 years, people in the top quarter of total sugar intake had 17% higher overall cancer risk and 51% higher breast cancer risk than those in the bottom quarter, and the links held for added sugars, sucrose and sugary drinks and after accounting for weight gain.46 In a review of 37 cohort studies, most found no link with cancer, but the authors flagged possible harm from added sugars and sugary drinks.47

Sugar and cancer risk across 37 cohort studies, by type of sugar
What was measured	What the studies found
Total sugar	11 of 15 studies found no link47
Sucrose	11 of 14 studies found no link47
Added sugars	2 of 5 studies found 60% to 95% higher risk47
Sugary foods and drinks	8 of 15 studies found 23% to 200% higher risk with more sugary drinks47

See cancer-fighting foods.

Is sugar addictive?

Sugar drives real cravings. In rats given sugar on an on-and-off schedule, researchers documented bingeing, withdrawal-like signs and changes in the brain's dopamine and opioid systems.48 I've said that processed foods and sugar can create dopamine spikes similar to addictive substances, so cutting them out of your diet can help with cravings.49 Most of that research is in animals, where the bingeing showed up with on-and-off access.50 The most useful target is the blood-sugar swing that sets up the next craving, covered in the steps below.

Mood may be part of the picture too. In the Whitehall II cohort of British civil servants (23,245 person-observations), men in the top third of sugar intake from sweet foods and drinks had 23% higher odds of a new common mental disorder five years later; a link with recurrent depression across both sexes wasn't significant once other diet-related factors were accounted for.51

How much sugar is too much?

Quick answer

The 2025–2030 Dietary Guidelines for Americans say no amount of added sugar is recommended as part of a healthy diet, and one meal should contain no more than 10 grams, about 2½ teaspoons.7 The American Heart Association's upper limits are 100 calories a day (about 6 teaspoons) for most women and 150 calories (about 9 teaspoons) for most men.52

Most Americans are well past that. The average adult 20 or older eats about 17 teaspoons of added sugar a day, and sugar-sweetened drinks, desserts and sweet snacks supply the most.53 The World Health Organization recommends keeping free sugars, which include honey and fruit juice, under 10% of your calories, and ideally under 5%.54 On a label, added sugar can show up as sucrose, cane sugar, beet sugar or turbinado sugar, and honey and molasses count too.7 See hidden sugar foods.

The average U.S. adult eats about 17 teaspoons of added sugar a day, nearly three times the limit for women

Source: CDC, Get the Facts: Added Sugars · American Heart Association, 2009 [53]Average intake from CDC survey data; the limits are the American Heart Association's upper limits of 150 calories a day for most men and 100 for most women.

How to cut back

In my Healthy Weight & Metabolic Reset protocol, I put it this way: "Put 30 g of protein in at breakfast and walk after lunch, and the craving loses its voice."55

Start with drinks. Sugary drinks are the leading source of added sugar, so swap soda and sweet tea for water, sparkling water with lemon or unsweetened herbal tea.53

Eat 30 grams of protein at breakfast to steady your blood sugar through the morning.55

Eat vegetables and protein first and carbohydrates last, which leads to a smaller blood-sugar rise than eating the same meal carbohydrates-first.56

Walk 10 to 15 minutes after meals. Light walking right after eating blunts the blood-sugar spike that follows.55 56

Read labels for sucrose, cane sugar, beet sugar and turbinado, and put back what lists them near the top.

Want help cutting back?

Ask Dr. Axe AI. Answers are grounded in this library, with sources shown.

Who should avoid cane sugar completely?

Quick answer

People with hereditary fructose intolerance must avoid sucrose entirely.57

Hereditary fructose intolerance is a rare inherited condition in which the body can't break down fructose, and sucrose is half fructose. Eating it can cause nausea, vomiting and low blood sugar, and over time, liver and kidney damage. The avoid list also covers fructose, sorbitol and sucralose, along with honey, agave syrup, molasses, maple-flavored syrup, and palm or coconut sugar, so several of the swaps above, including honey and coconut sugar, aren't safe with this condition.57

For children, the 2025–2030 Dietary Guidelines advise avoiding added sugars in infancy and early childhood and say no amount is recommended for children 5 to 10.7

Good to know before you cut sugar or swap it:

With hereditary fructose intolerance, avoid sucrose and the swaps that contain sucrose or fructose, such as honey, molasses and coconut sugar
On insulin or other glucose-lowering medication, watch your readings as you cut back; your doctor adjusts the dose
For babies and young children, no added sugar, and never honey before age 1
With asthma or a past severe reaction to bee stings or bee products, don't assume honey is safe for you

The bottom line

Should you eat cane sugar?

I'd be very careful with cane sugar. Raw and less-refined cane sugar beats the refined, processed kind, but better isn't the same as healthy. It's still sugar, with almost nothing else your body needs, which is why it's on my avoid list, organic included. The trials that cut sugar show real payoffs: less liver fat within weeks, easier weight control, and lower blood pressure and triglycerides.

When you want something sweet, reach for raw honey, a far superior option to cane sugar, and use it the way Proverbs advises, sparingly. Monk fruit, stevia and allulose come next, and maple syrup, coconut sugar and date paste belong in small amounts, because natural sugars are still sugars. Start with drinks, read labels, eat protein at breakfast and walk after meals.

Your body was built to heal, and every sugary drink or dessert you replace gives it a better chance to do that work.

Get the free Insulin Resistance & Prediabetes protocol

Four phases, the foods that lower insulin and a 7-day meal plan. Have recent bloodwork? Analyze it free.

Free with your Dr. Axe account (email or Google). You'll also get the protocol's short email series and the Dr. Axe newsletter; unsubscribe anytime.

Open the free protocol →

Cane sugar: frequently asked questions

Is cane sugar healthier than regular sugar?

Less-refined cane sugar is a better choice than refined, processed sugar, in Dr. Axe's view, but it's still sugar, very low in nutrients, and not healthy, so be very careful with it. Turbinado and brown sugar keep only a few more milligrams of minerals per teaspoon than white sugar, and all three are still 94% to 99.8% sucrose.1 2 19

Is cane sugar natural?

It comes from a plant, and Dr. Axe calls its less-refined forms, such as turbinado and panela, natural; they're as close to the cane as sugar gets. Boiling the juice down still leaves a product that's about 92% to 99% sucrose,2 15 and as he points out, nowhere in nature would you get that much sugar as an isolated compound.9 In his view, natural doesn't make it healthy.

Is cane sugar the same as granulated sugar?

Chemically, yes: both are sucrose. In the U.S., a bag labeled only "sugar" may come from sugar beets, which supply 55% to 60% of the sugar produced at home.3

Is organic cane sugar better for you?

Only in how it's grown. Under USDA organic rules, it's produced without synthetic herbicides such as glyphosate and without genetically engineered crops.23 In your body it's the same sucrose, which is why Dr. Axe keeps organic sugars on his avoid list.8

Is cane sugar better than high-fructose corn syrup?

Dr. Axe would choose cane sugar over high-fructose corn syrup but doesn't recommend eating much of either.22

Does cane sugar raise blood sugar?

Yes. Half of every sucrose molecule is glucose, which enters your blood after you eat it, and a steady load of sugar can leave your cells less responsive to insulin.25

What is the glycemic index of cane sugar?

Sucrose, the sugar in cane sugar, averages a glycemic index of 65 on a scale where glucose is 100, between the low (55 or less) and high (70 or more) ranges.59 It sits below glucose because its fructose half barely raises blood sugar and goes mainly to the liver.34 59 Honey averages 61 in the same tables, so it isn't a low-glycemic sweetener either.59

How much cane sugar is safe per day?

The 2025–2030 Dietary Guidelines say no amount of added sugar is recommended and cap one meal at 10 grams, about 2½ teaspoons.7 The American Heart Association's upper limits are about 6 teaspoons a day for most women and 9 for most men.52

What is evaporated cane juice?

It's cane sugar under another name. Since 2016, the FDA has advised that sweeteners made from sugarcane be declared on labels as "sugar."12

What is the best substitute for cane sugar?

Raw honey is Dr. Axe's number-one sweetener, followed by monk fruit, stevia and allulose.10 He considers honey a far superior option, but even honey should be used sparingly. In recipes that don't need heat, use 2 teaspoons of honey for each tablespoon of sugar.8

Is honey healthier than cane sugar?

Yes. Dr. Axe considers honey a far superior option to cane sugar, though, as the Bible says, even honey should be used sparingly. In lab testing, store-bought honey carried 0.16 millimoles of antioxidant capacity per 100 grams versus under 0.01 for refined sugar,21 and in a meta-analysis of 18 trials, mostly comparing honey with people's usual diet, a median of about 2 tablespoons a day for 8 weeks raised HDL cholesterol and lowered fasting blood sugar, LDL cholesterol and triglycerides.28

Is coconut sugar better than cane sugar?

Coconut sugar is on Dr. Axe's sweetener list, and cane sugar is on his avoid list,8 but coconut sugar is still mostly sucrose.30 Dr. Axe ranks it below raw honey and says everyone should be careful even with natural sugars, so use it in small amounts.

Does sugar cause inflammation?

It can raise inflammation markers. In a 10-week trial of 41 overweight adults, sucrose-sweetened drinks and foods raised haptoglobin and transferrin, two inflammation markers, compared with artificially sweetened versions.43

Is sugar addictive?

It can act that way. Rats given sugar on an on-and-off schedule binge and show withdrawal-like behavior,48 and Dr. Axe notes that sugar can create dopamine spikes similar to addictive substances.49 His approach to cravings is to steady blood sugar: 30 grams of protein at breakfast and a walk after lunch.55

Does sugar feed cancer?

It's more nuanced than the slogan,45 but the cohort data support cutting back: in a French cohort of 101,279 adults, the highest sugar intake was linked to 17% higher overall cancer risk.46

Can people with diabetes eat cane sugar?

Cane sugar raises blood sugar like any sugar, and the Dietary Guidelines recommend no added sugar as part of a healthy diet.7 On insulin or other glucose-lowering medication, watch your readings as you cut back; your doctor adjusts the dose.

Freshness & update log

October 15, 2026 — Updated the optimal lab ranges to DrAxe.com's current standard.

October 9, 2026 — Trimmed repeated book references.

October 6, 2026 — Matched the antioxidant figures for raw cane sugar, honey, maple syrup and brown sugar to the study's own table of results.

September 30, 2026 (second update) — Turned the "How sugar works" cards into a five-step cascade from sucrose to liver fat and insulin sensitivity, with the measured and proposed steps labeled, and added blood uric acid from the 16-day sucrose trial. Added where sugarcane was domesticated (a 2025 genetic study) and the King James Version's count of honey (56 times, plus honeycomb 9) against none for sugar. Added sucrose's glycemic index (65) to the nutrition facts, a honey-swap box with the sugar and calories per spoonful and the per-meal cap in teaspoons of honey, a table of the cancer cohort findings by type of sugar with the exact study counts, and a chart of average added-sugar intake against the American Heart Association limits. Added two FAQs, "Is cane sugar natural?" and "What is the glycemic index of cane sugar?" Varied the wording where Dr. Axe's position repeated word for word, kept the position itself unchanged, and simplified the liver-fat and blood-pressure evidence cards. Added 3 references (60 in all).

September 30, 2026 (revision) — Added Dr. Axe's position on cane sugar and honey (Dr. Axe, Sept 30, 2026): be very careful with cane sugar; less-refined cane sugar is a better choice than refined, processed sugar, but it's still sugar, very low in nutrients, and not healthy; honey is a far superior option; everyone should be careful even with natural sugars; and, as the Bible says, even honey should be used sparingly. Added Proverbs 25:16 and 25:27 (KJV). Explained what "better" means for less-refined cane sugar and noted that a bag labeled "cane sugar" can be fully refined white sugar. Added honey's measured antioxidant capacity and clarified that most trials in the honey meta-analysis compared honey with people's usual diet. Tightened the sucrose and type 2 diabetes finding to one clause, dated the industry-history sentence correctly, and added the Whitehall II sample size.

September 30, 2026 — Rebuilt the 2025 page ("Cane Sugar: Is It Any Healthier than Common Sugar?") to the current DrAxe.com standard under Dr. Axe's byline. Replaced the list of "potential benefits," including the antioxidant and mood claims, which the research doesn't support at food amounts, with graded findings from randomized trials, meta-analyses and cohorts on liver fat, weight, blood pressure and blood fats, type 2 diabetes, heart disease and teeth, and added sections on inflammation, cancer, and cravings and mood. Corrected the comparison with white sugar: both are sucrose, and U.S. granulated sugar may come from beets. Updated the high-fructose corn syrup comparison with a 2021 controlled trial and the organic sourcing difference. Rebuilt the nutrition facts from USDA FoodData Central at a one-teaspoon serving and added a comparison of cane sugar types. Removed sugar alcohols, including xylitol and erythritol, from the recommended alternatives and added Dr. Axe's ranked swaps with the 2023 honey meta-analysis. Added the Dr. Axe Score, guidance for hereditary fructose intolerance, blood-sugar medicines and young children, and 57 numbered references.

References

Dr. Josh Axe, DC, DNM, CNS

Doctor of Natural Medicine · Founder, DrAxe.com

Dr. Axe is a certified doctor of natural medicine, clinical nutritionist, and multiple New York Times bestselling author. He has spent 20+ years in clinical practice helping people heal at the root cause and founded one of the most-visited natural-health platforms in the world.

Read the full bio →

This article is for educational purposes. See our medical disclaimer.

On this page

What is it?
Cane vs. granulated sugar
Is it healthier?
Nutrition facts
Better swaps
Is it bad for you?
How it works
Benefits of cutting back
Inflammation
Cancer
Cravings and mood
How much is too much?
Who should avoid it
The bottom line
Should you eat cane sugar?
FAQ

Quick facts

What it isSucrose crystallized from sugarcane juice
One teaspoon16 calories, 4.2 g sugar, no fiber
Dr. Axe's swapRaw honey, used sparingly; then monk fruit, stevia or allulose
Upper limitNo more than 10 g of added sugar per meal (2025–2030 Dietary Guidelines)

Ask Dr. Axe AI

Ask a question→

Dr. Axe Protocol

Insulin Resistance & Prediabetes

90-day protocol

Free with your Dr. Axe account

View the protocol →