Based on sales on the over past decade, cottage cheese seems to be making a comeback. Perhaps this is because it’s high in protein and low in carbs, therefore considered by some to be the perfect cheese for both low-carb and low-fat diets.
Turns out, this unique-looking dairy product has some impressive benefits.
Why is it healthy to eat cottage cheese? It can help control your appetite, provides some important nutrients, such as phosphorus, and can even provide probiotics just like yogurt.
However, not all cottage cheese is treated equal.
The Cornucopia Institute, which produces science-based reports about food products to help inform consumers, recently completed an investigation into the cottage cheese industry, ranking over 100 types. The findings revealed there’s a wide variety in terms of quality of cottage cheeses — depending on factors including type of production (conventional vs. organic), amount of processing, and whether sugar and other additives are used.
What Is Cottage Cheese?
Cottage cheese is a mild, soft, creamy white cheese. It’s typically considered a fresh cheese since it does not go through an aging process.
How is cottage cheese made, and what does cottage cheese taste like?
It comes from curds of pasteurized cow’s milk. It’s found with varying amounts of milk fat — from non-fat to reduced-fat and regular.
You can also find it in different curd sizes, ranging from small to large. And for those who need to skip the lactose, you can purchase the lactose-free version as well as whipped and low-sodium.
What’s a healthy serving of cottage cheese? According to most labels, one serving is between a half cup and one cup.
If you add ingredients, such as fruit or granola, having a half cup may be perfect as a healthy snack or high-protein breakfast.
One cup (226 grams) of 1 percent milk-fat cottage cheese contains about:
- 163 calories
- 6.1 grams carbohydrates
- 28 grams protein
- 2.3 grams fat
- 303 milligrams phosphorus (30 percent DV)
- 20.3 micrograms selenium (29 percent DV)
- 1.4 micrograms vitamin B12 (24 percent DV)
- 0.4 milligram riboflavin (22 percent DV)
- 138 milligrams calcium (14 percent DV)
- 0.2 milligram vitamin B6 (8 percent DV)
- 27.1 micrograms folate (7 percent DV)
- 194 milligrams potassium (6 percent DV)
- 0.9 milligram zinc (6 percent DV)
- 0.5 milligram pantothenic acid (5 percent DV)
What are the benefits of cottage cheese? Not only is it a high-protein food, but it contains phosphorous, selenium, riboflavin and calcium, just to name a few nutrients.
Protein is the winner here, with 28 grams in a one-cup serving.
Additionally, cottage cheese is a staple of the Budwig diet.
What is the Budwig diet? The German Government’s senior expert, Dr. Johanna Budwig, was noted in 1952 for her research of processed foods and how they negatively affect our health.
Through this research, she helped others understand what to eat and what not eat. One recommendation she includes is cottage cheese.
In fact, she suggests that “that the health of your cells can quickly be reversed by consuming a mixture of cottage cheese (quark), flaxseeds, and flaxseed oil.”
Here’s more about the benefits that cottage cheese nutrition provides:
1. Contains B12
Even though it’s easier to get vitamin B12 in meat products, some dairy products contain a good amount of B12. Cottage cheese is one example, coming in at about a quarter of the recommended daily intake of the nutrient.
We need B12 — something that vegans struggle with in their diets — because it provides proper function and development of the brain, nerves, blood cells and much more.
Vitamin B12 benefits including helping lower high homocysteine levels in the blood, especially when combined with folic acid and sometimes vitamin B6. This is important since too much homocysteine can become toxic in the body and cause heart problems and neurological issues.
2. Builds Bones and Helps Treat Osteoporosis
Cottage cheese is a food high in phosphorus, and when combined with calcium, it can help build strong bones and potentially protect against fractures or osteoporosis. In fact, studies shows that the two must work together to be effective.
One cup of cottage cheese contains about 138 milligrams of calcium, making it a great choice for bone building — possibly better than supplements.
3. Helps the Body Detox While Providing Energy
Phosphorous does more than help develop strong, healthy bones. It also helps create a healthy acid level in the body.
Phosphorous is the second most abundant mineral in the body, and it’s pretty important since it helps rid the body of waste.
Phosphorous also affects how the body handles energy and minimizes muscle pain after workouts by helping repair tissues and cells. It helps by absorbing B vitamins, which are key to healthy energy production.
Without phosphorus, our bodies may feel weak and sore, resulting in chronic fatigue.
4. May Assist in Weight Loss
Cottage cheese contains a lot of protein, and according to loads of research, protein can help you lose weight as long as you don’t overdo it.
Why? It may help you feel fuller and therefore help you eat less, and it promotes muscle building, which can help with burning calories.
It’s thought that protein foods help people achieve satiety, which, in turn, reduces the appetite by increasing the hormone levels of GLP-1, peptide YY and cholecystokinin. At the same time, it helps reduce levels of the hunger hormone, ghrelin.
5. Can Help You Achieve Ketosis
Full-fat dairy products are on the yes list for a keto diet food list. That means healthy fats are a good choice, and while you want to keep your dairy to a minimum since it can be hard to digest, if a keto diet is something you’re following, a full-fat cottage cheese can help.
Cottage Cheese vs. Yogurt vs. Other Cheeses
You may be wondering which is better: Cottage cheese nutrition or Greek yogurt nutrition? Well, there are pros for both, making it a close race.
Both make quick, high-protein snacks and are good sources of calcium. Low-fat yogurt has a bit less fat than cottage cheese, but it’s higher in carbs.
Some regular low-fat yogurt options contain a lot of sugar, coming in around 17 grams per cup, especially the versions with added fruits and sugars.
Sodium is considerably lower in yogurt compared to cottage cheese, which contains over 800 milligrams per cup, compared to 65 in most yogurts.
Overall, the one advantage yogurt has over cottage cheese is the probiotics content. However, its flavor is more tart because it’s fermented, which may turn some people off.
We know that probiotics foster a healthy gut. This characteristic may make yogurt easier to digest for some people.
When it comes to providing protein and a low calorie cost, cottage cheese is a winner.
According to the British Heart Foundation, mascarpone, stilton, cheddar, parmesan and brie are high in grams of fat per 100-gram serving, ranging from 29–44 grams, with mascarpone at the top of that number. Conversely, cottage cheese nutrition contains four grams, while ricotta contains eight.
If watching your fat consumption is important, leaning toward cottage cheese will make a difference.
How It’s Made (Plus Recipes)
Cottage cheese is a soft, fresh curd cheese that’s uncured. By curdling milk and draining the whey, you end up with either small-curd or large-curd cottage cheese.
What distinguishes them is that small-curd is made without rennet and the large-curd is made with rennet.
What is rennet? Rennet is an enzyme produced in the stomach of ruminant mammals that’s added to speed up the curdling.
It also helps coagulate the curds so they don’t break apart.
Healthiest Types to Buy:
|Kalona Super Natural 4%||★★★★★||Yes||Kalona Supernatural||1850|
|Kalona Super Natural 2% Reduced Fat||★★★★★||Yes||Kalona Supernatural||1850|
|Nancy's Whole Milk||★★★★★||Yes||Nancy's||1825|
|Nancy's Organic Probiotic Low Fat||★★★★★||Yes||Nancy's||1825|
|Good Culture Organic Whole Milk||★★★★★||Yes||Good Culture||1795|
|Westby Organic Small Curd 4%||★★★★★||Yes||Westby Creamery||1783|
|Organic Valley 4%||★★★★||Yes||Organic Valley||1470|
|Organic Valley 2% Low Fat||★★★★||Yes||Organic Valley||1470|
|365 Low Fat 1.5%||★★★★||Yes||Whole Foods||1370|
|365 4%||★★★★||Yes||Whole Foods||1370|
|Good Culture Organic Mango||★★★★||Yes||Good Culture||1345|
|Good Culture Organic Bluebarry Acai Chia||★★★★||Yes||Good Culture||1345|
|Good Culture Organic Strawberry Chia||★★★★||Yes||Good Culture||1345|
|Good Culture Organic Pineapple||★★★★||Yes||Good Culture||1345|
|Clover Organic 1.5%||★★★★||Yes||Clover Dairy||1270|
|Clover Organic 2% Low Fat||★★★★||Yes||Clover Dairy||1270|
|Horizon Regular Small Curd 4%||★★★★||Yes||Horizon||1170|
|Nancy's Natural Probiotic Low Fat||★★★||No||Nancy's||1025|
|Horizon Low Fat||★★★||Yes||Horizon||970|
|Good Culture 2%||★★★||No||Good Culture||895|
|Daisy Low-fat||★★★||No||Daisy Brands||850|
|Daisy 4%||★★★||No||Daisy Brands||850|
|Good Culture 4%||★★★||No||Good Culture||645|
|Muuna Plain Low Fat||★★||No||Bright Food||500|
|Muuna Classic 4%||★★||No||Bright Food||500|
|Breakstone's Fat Free||★★||No||Kraft||420|
|Knudsen Small Curd 4%||★★||No||Kraft||420|
|Knudsen Fat Free||★★||No||Kraft||400|
|Trader Joes Fat Free||★★||No||Trader Joes||400|
|Good Culture Strawberry 2%||★★||No||Good Culture||385|
|Good Culture Pineapple 2%||★★||No||Good Culture||385|
|Good Culture Peach 2%||★★||No||Good Culture||385|
|Good Culture Blueberry 2%||★★||No||Good Culture||385|
|Breakstone's Small Curd 2%||★★||No||Kraft||340|
|Dairy Pure Mix-in Pineapple||★★||No||Dean Foods||340|
|Dairy Pure Mix-in Strawberry & Almond||★★||No||Dean Foods||340|
|Dairy Pure Mix-in Blueberry||★★||No||Dean Foods||340|
|Dairy Pure Mix-in Peach & Pecan||★★||No||Dean Foods||340|
|Lactaid 4%||★★||No||HP Hood||340|
|Breakstone's Small Curd 2%, 30% less sodium||★★||No||Kraft||320|
|Muuna Vanilla||★★||No||Bright Food||320|
|Market Pantry 4%||★★||No||Target||300|
|Market Pantry 1%||★★||No||Target||300|
|Market Pantry Fat Free||★★||No||Target||300|
|Friendship Strawberry 1%||★★||No||Saputo Dairy Foods||260|
|Friendship Peach 1%||★★||No||Saputo Dairy Foods||260|
|Friendship Pineapple 1%||★★||No||Saputo Dairy Foods||260|
|Breakstone's Mango Habanero||★||No||Kraft||240|
|Breakstone's Honey Vanilla||★||No||Kraft||240|
|Muuna Pineapple 2%||★||No||Bright Food||240|
|Muuna Black Cherry||★||No||Bright Food||240|
|Muuna Raspberry||★||No||Bright Food||240|
|Muuna Mango||★||No||Bright Food||240|
|Muuna Strawberry||★||No||Bright Food||240|
|Muuna Peach||★||No||Bright Food||240|
|Muuna Blueberry||★||No||Bright Food||240|
|Westby Large Curd||★||No||Westby Creamery||233|
|Friendship Pot Style 2%||★||No||Saputo Dairy Foods||220|
|Friendship No Salt Added 1%||★||No||Saputo Dairy Foods||220|
|Friendship Whipped 1%||★||No||Saputo Dairy Foods||220|
|Friendship Small Curd 1% Lowfat||★||No||Saputo Dairy Foods||220|
|Friendship California Style 4%||★||No||Saputo Dairy Foods||220|
|Knudsen Pineapple Low fat||★||No||Kraft||220|
|Trader Joes Small Curd 4%||★||No||Trader Joes||200|
|Westby Small Curd 2%||★||No||Westby Creamery||153|
|Westby Small Curd Low-Fat||★||No||Westby Creamery||153|
|Westby Fat-Free||★||No||Westby Creamery||153|
|Borden Fat-Free||★||No||Dairy Farmers of America||120|
|Borden Large Curd 4%||★||No||Dairy Farmers of America||120|
|Borden 1%||★||No||Dairy Farmers of America||120|
|Borden Small Curd 4%||★||No||Dairy Farmers of America||120|
|Cabot No Fat||★||No||Agri-Mark Cooperative||120|
|Cabot 4%||★||No||Agri-Mark Cooperative||120|
|Great Value Large Curd 4%||★||No||Wal-Mart||120|
|Great Value Small Curd 1%||★||No||Wal-Mart||120|
|Great Value Small Curd 4%||★||No||Wal-Mart||120|
|Kemps 1%||★||No||Dairy Farmers of America||120|
|Kemps 2%||★||No||Dairy Farmers of America||120|
|Kemps w/ Chives 4%||★||No||Dairy Farmers of America||120|
|Kemps Small Curd 4%||★||No||Dairy Farmers of America||120|
|Kemps Large Curd||★||No||Dairy Farmers of America||120|
|Publix Fat Free||★||No||Publix||120|
|Publix Low Fat||★||No||Publix||120|
|Publix Large Curd||★||No||Publix||120|
|Publix Small Curd||★||No||Publix||120|
|Harris Teeter Small Curd Fat Free||★||No||Kroger||100|
|Land O'Lakes Large Curd 4%||★||No||Land O'Lakes||100|
|Land O'Lakes Small Curd 4%||★||No||Land O'Lakes||100|
|Land O'Lakes Small Curd 1%||★||No||Land O'Lakes||100|
|Land O'Lakes Small Curd Fat Free||★||No||Land O'Lakes||100|
|Land O'Lakes Small Curd 2%||★||No||Land O'Lakes||100|
|Friendship Small Curd 0%||★||No||Saputo Dairy Foods||40|
|Friendship Pineapple 0%||★||No||Saputo Dairy Foods||40|
|Kemps Mixed Berry||★||No||Dairy Farmers of America||40|
|Kemps Honey Pear||★||No||Dairy Farmers of America||40|
|Kemps Peach||★||No||Dairy Farmers of America||40|
|Kemps Pineapple||★||No||Dairy Farmers of America||40|
|Kemps Strawberry||★||No||Dairy Farmers of America||40|
|Kemps Fat Free||★||No||Dairy Farmers of America||40|
|Great Value Small Curd Fat Free||★||No||Wal-Mart||20|
You can purchase cottage cheese in most grocery stores. There are a few things you want to look for on the label to ensure you purchase from a quality brand.
As mentioned above, a 2020 Cornucopia report, called “Weighing the Curds,” was published to help consumers choose the most nutritious cottage cheese options and avoid overly processed types. Here are some of the report’s major findings and tips for choosing the best product:
- Organic cottage cheese products seem to be far superior to their conventional counterparts, due to less use of additives, gums and thickeners. Organic cottage cheese is also always made from non-GMO ingredients and more likely to be made from grass-fed cows’ milk.
- Cottage cheese from grass-fed cows is more likely to have increased nutritional benefits (including higher omega-3s and conjugated linoleic acid) when compared to cheese made from milk derived from dairy cows raised in conventional confinements. Organic standards require that organic dairy cows be on pasture during the grazing season and have adequate time outdoors, allowing them to eat their natural diet.
- Some manufacturers heavily sweeten cottage cheese to improve its flavor, much like with the yogurt industry. Always read the labels, and go for the versions that don’t have added sugars or artificial sweeteners.
- Thickeners in cottage cheese can lead to gastrointestinal inflammatory reactions in some people. Check the ingredient label for additives and gums, such as carrageenan. These are used to make the products “creamier” but do not provide other nutritional benefits.
- The use of “natural flavors” and cornstarch/modified food starch is also more common in conventional cottage cheeses. Synthetic, petroleum-based solvents, such as propane and neurotoxic hexane, may also be added to preserve the cheese. Ideally all of these ingredients should be avoided since they are commonly made with herbicides and GMOs.
- Conventional cottage cheese that contains fruit and other mix-in additives is also likely to contain residues of synthetic chemicals. Flavored types are more likely to contain added colors and flavors too, so choose plain products whenever possible and add your own toppings.
How to Make Cottage Cheese:
Did you know that you can make cottage cheese right at home? You can.
Try the following cottage cheese recipe:
- 1 gallon pasteurized organic skim milk
- 3/4 cup white vinegar
- 1 ¼ teaspoons kosher salt
- ½ cup organic heavy cream
- Pour the milk into a large saucepan and place over medium heat on the stove. Heat to 120 degrees F. You can check this using a food safe thermometer.
- Remove from heat and slowly pour in the vinegar. Gently stir for about 2 minutes. The curd will begin to separate from the whey. Cover with a lid, and let it sit at room temperature for approximately a half hour.
- Now, pour the milk mixture into a colander lined with a cheesecloth. Let it drain for 5–6 minutes. Rinse under cold water by gathering the edges of the cloth first. Do this for 3–5 minutes until the curd is completely cooled. Make sure you gently squeeze and move the mixture while within the cloth during this cooling process.
- Now that it has cooled, squeeze the cloth as dry as possible and transfer the mixture to a medium mixing bowl. Add the salt and stir. Break up the curd into smaller pieces as you stir.
- When you’re ready to serve, stir in the heavy cream, but not until then. Otherwise, store in a container with a lid, and place in the refrigerator.
As far as taste, it’s very mild, which makes it a great choice to blend with other foods.
What should you eat cottage cheese with? You can add it to lasagne or nut butters, such as almond butter or sunflower seed butter, to make a delicious spread.
Here are some more ways to incorporate cottage cheese into your diet:
- Pancakes or waffles: Mix it into the batter as a substitute for milk.
- Lasagna: Use cottage cheese instead of ricotta cheese or half and half.
- Salads: Top your favorite salads for added protein.
- Fruit: Mix it with berries, bananas or grilled peaches.
- Granola: Top it with granola and drizzle with honey.
- Sour cream: Cottage cheese makes a great sour cream substitute.
- Smoothies: Blend it with some milk and fruits for a fruit smoothie.
- Baked goods: Use it in your muffins, cakes and bread recipes.
- Scrambled eggs: Add to your eggs for extra creaminess.
- Nut butter: Mix it with almond butter, then spread onto celery with raisins.
- Salsa: Add it to salsa as a dip or baked potato topping.
- Toast: Serve it on toast. The nut butter blend goes well here too.
- Pumpkin: Mix it with organic smashed or roasted pumpkin, and top it off with a few nuts.
Risks and Side Effects
Can you eat cottage cheese every day? As long as you’re not lactose intolerant and your diet is varied, this shouldn’t be a problem.
However, there are a few things you should know:
- Consuming very high amounts of protein may contribute to kidney problems, so consider sticking to a daily intake that doesn’t provide more than you need.
- It may cause problems if you are lactose intolerant. Issues include diarrhea, bloating, cramps, gas and an upset stomach. Lactose intolerance ultimately makes digesting dairy products a pretty big challenge for some. While your doctor can help, you may need to avoid dairy altogether. You can find lactose-free versions in the grocery store.
- It may cause allergic reactions. If you experience hives, itching, swelling and/or breathing trouble, make sure to stop eating it immediately and contact your doctor.
- It may raise your blood pressure due to its high sodium content. If blood pressure is a problem for you, make your own to keep your sodium intake in check.
- Cottage cheese works well with a keto diet, provides a vegetarian protein option, and is a decent source of calcium and phosphorous.
- As always, pay attention to what you buy since there are plenty of options that have a lot of additives and sugar.
- Make your own, and make sure to read labels when purchasing from the grocery store.